archives

Press Releases

This category contains 19 posts

New Bowel Cancer UK report on Lynch Syndrome


Families devastated by cancer as health bodies pass the buck

Our new findings reveal a shocking picture of delayed testing for diagnosis, poor management and unacceptable long waiting times for genetic testing for people diagnosed with Lynch syndrome – a genetic condition similar to the BRCA gene for people with a high risk of breast cancer.

  • We carried out a nationwide survey of people with Lynch syndrome.
  • An estimated 175,000 people have Lynch syndrome in the UK. Most people (95%) with Lynch syndrome do not know they have it because of a lack of systematic testing. If you have Lynch syndrome there is a 50% chance that your children, brothers and sisters also have the condition.
  • People with Lynch syndrome need to be identified, so they can be regularly monitored to reduce their risk of bowel cancer. In some cases the risk of developing bowel cancer from this inherited condition is as much as 80% and it also increases the risk of other cancers including ovarian cancer, stomach cancer and womb cancer.
    An estimated 1,100 cases of bowel cancer can be attributed to Lynch syndrome each year – many of them under the age of 50.
  • Currently people with Lynch syndrome are managed locally with mixed results across the country.  This means those at high risk who require coordinated, timely and high quality care in order to reduce and manage their risk of bowel cancer fail to receive it. There’s a lack of leadership locally and nationally, with no body or organisation taking responsibility to address these issues to improve the identification and management of this serious genetic condition. In the meantime whole families are being devastated by cancer.
  • The buck stops with the UK Health Ministers. We’ve started a petition calling on them to step in and take responsibility for identifying and managing people with Lynch syndrome by implementing the charity’s top three recommendations:
    • Develop a national registry of people identified as having Lynch syndrome. A registry could increase our understanding of the condition, including knowing how many people are affected & whether there are any regional differences in treatment, care and outcomes. Our survey found that 87% of respondents identified with Lynch syndrome would consent to be part of a genetics registry.
    • Establish a national surveillance programme to improve the management of people with the genetic condition. 49% of respondents to our survey experienced delays to their planned colonoscopy appointment date, with 78% waiting more than six weeks.
    • Comprehensive UK guidelines should be developed that set out best practice for the clinical management of people with Lynch syndrome.

51-year-old Caroline found out she had Lynch syndrome after she was diagnosed with bowel cancer.
“I was referred to a geneticist after chemotherapy, where I was diagnosed with Lynch syndrome. I had never heard of this, but it highlighted my family history. My whole family has been devastated by cancer. My mum died of ovarian cancer, her mum died of bowel cancer, my mum’s brother died from cancer in the liver, mum’s sister died from ovarian cancer and my mum’s other brother died from lung cancer. I have two children, they’re too young to be tested at the moment but that day will come.

“I waited seven months for my genetic counsellor; I don’t know why it took so long. At the appointment we discussed my family history and she said I most likely had Lynch syndrome. A blood sample was taken to confirm the syndrome but I had to chase and chase for over a year to get the results. I’m now waiting for a letter to invite me on to the aspirin trial and I think I will be chasing that up too.  Having bowel cancer is stressful enough and it’s not helpful having to chase and inform healthcare professionals about Lynch syndrome.

“More information needs to be provided to healthcare professionals about Lynch syndrome so it’s not the patient informing them.” Read more about Caroline’s story  

Deborah Alsina MBE, Chief Executive at Bowel Cancer UK, says:
“Until there is clear local and national leadership and a firm commitment to improve the services for people at high risk of developing bowel cancer, the estimated 175,000 people who carry this inherited faulty gene will continue to fall through the gaps of health bodies because they are reluctant to take responsibility.

For example in Wales and England the Breast Cancer Screening Programme has set a precedent for a national screening programme managing the surveillance of those with a known genetic mutation such as BRCA1 or 2 that increases the risk of cancer. A similar programme must now be introduced for those with Lynch syndrome. Until then generations of families will be devastated and lives needlessly lost.”

Dr Kevin Monahan, Consultant Gastroenterologist at West Middlesex University Hospital and a member of our medical advisory board, says:
“These latest findings give us an extremely valuable but also worrying insight into the challenges people with Lynch syndrome face.  With such a high risk of developing cancer, it’s vital this group is properly identified and managed by the health service in order to save as many lives as possible. We know in many areas of treatment and care too many people are being failed and this has to change.”

To address these issues, we have three top recommendations for a health body to implement:

 1. Develop a national registry of people identified as having Lynch syndrome

The UK’s understanding of the number of people with Lynch syndrome is limited – only 6,000 gene carriers are currently known, as testing is not carried out systematically across the country. By collecting anonymised data on gene carriers we can increase our knowledge and understanding of Lynch syndrome, including knowing how many people are affected and whether there are any regional differences in treatment, care and outcomes.

Our survey found that 87% of respondents identified with Lynch syndrome would consent to be part of a genetics registry if adopted in the UK to further research, raise awareness, coordinate consistent care services and to help others in the same situation.

2. Establish a national surveillance programme to improve the management of people with the genetic condition

By knowing if people have Lynch syndrome, the individual and their family can be offered a surveillance programme to receive regular colonoscopy, which can reduce their chance of dying from bowel cancer by 72 per cent. It will also reduce their risk of a recurrence of cancer, and inform treatment options.

Guidelines from the British Society of Gastroenterology (BSG) recommend that people who have Lynch syndrome are placed in a surveillance programme to receive regular colonoscopy every 18 months to two years, depending on their risk. However, 49% told us in our survey they had experienced delays to their planned appointment date and 78% of these reported waiting more than six weeks beyond their planned procedure date.

The inequalities and postcode lottery of care caused by the current localised approach to surveillance of these high risk patients could be addressed by implementing a national surveillance programme, adopting a similar approach to the national bowel cancer screening programme. The national bowel cancer screening programme, aimed at the general popular aged over 60, provides an efficient high quality service with strict waiting time targets meaning patients are seen on time.

3. Develop comprehensive UK guidelines that set out best practice for the clinical management of Lynch syndrome

An inconsistent approach to managing people at higher risk of bowel cancer will undermine efforts to save lives from this treatable disease.

– See more at: https://www.bowelcanceruk.org.uk/media-centre/news-and-blog/families-devastated-by-cancer-as-health-bodies-pass-the-buck/#sthash.7VT0XGwc.dpuf

Advertisements

New findings show variation of genetic testing in the UK could lead to cancer devastating whole families


Results of Bowel Cancer UK Study Released

bowelcancerukToday (Monday 8 August) along with the Royal College of Pathologists we have published findings which show that people under 50 diagnosed with bowel cancer are not being tested for Lynch syndrome – a genetic condition that increases the risk of bowel cancer by 80 per cent.

Lynch syndrome is an inherited condition which puts people at a much higher risk of developing bowel cancer as well as increasing the risk of other cancers including ovarian cancer, stomach cancer and womb cancer.

Lynch syndrome is estimated to cause 1,000 cases of bowel cancer each year, many of them under the age of 50. Yet fewer than five per cent of people with the condition have been identified.

The Royal College of Pathologists clinical guidelines state that a simple set of tests, which can help identify people with Lynch syndrome, should be carried out automatically on all people diagnosed with bowel cancer under the age of 50 at the time of diagnosis.

Performing this type of test can detect people at greater risk of recurrence, informs treatment options and helps identify those with family members who may also have the condition and be at risk of bowel cancer.  If you have Lynch syndrome there is a 50 per cent chance that your children, brothers and sisters also have the condition.

By knowing if people have Lynch syndrome, the patient and their family can be offered a surveillance programme to receive regular colonoscopy, which can reduce their chance of dying from bowel cancer by 72 per cent.

However, Bowel Cancer UK and the Royal College of Pathologists found that 29 per cent of hospitals across the UK do not test patients under 50 diagnosed with bowel cancer.

Of those that do carry out the test, only just over half (56 per cent) perform the test automatically as stated in the guidelines. In many cases, hospitals are even delaying the test until after treatment for bowel cancer with only one in 10 (11 per cent) testing prior to treatment.

Asha Kaur, Policy Manager at Bowel Cancer UK said: “Since we carried out the last Freedom of Information (FOI) request on this issue in 2015 there has been a 46 per cent increase in the number of hospitals testing those under 50 diagnosed with bowel cancer.

However, the guidelines have now been in place two years and there are still 40 hospitals in England alone not doing the test at all plus a huge variation in approach to testing across the UK.

We understand that a number of hospitals face challenges implementing the guidelines however many have developed innovative solutions and local approaches to overcome these barriers. Testing should be performed at diagnosis and that’s just not happening. We urge hospitals across the UK to work together to carry out this lifesaving test.

Lynch syndrome has a devastating effect on families and we hear every day how generations have been affected by cancer because of this genetic condition. But it doesn’t have to be this way. There is a simple and cost effective test that can detect Lynch syndrome and then place people in surveillance to help stop bowel cancer.”

Andy Sutton, father of Stephen Sutton who died at the age of 19 from bowel cancer and became a household name by raising millions for charity, said: “I know from personal experience how vital it is that every single person under 50 who is diagnosed with bowel cancer is offered testing for Lynch syndrome.  I was eventually offered it but only after I had been diagnosed with bowel cancer second time round. So I was pleased to hear that 110 out of 156 hospitals in the UK are now testing for Lynch syndrome, but I’d like to see every hospital doing it.”

Professor Tim Helliwell, Vice-President of The Royal College of Pathologists said: “We are pleased to see that most hospitals have followed the College’s guidelines and routinely make available the tests for Lynch syndrome. While we recognise that there are barriers for some Trusts in being able to routinely offer testing, we would encourage local multi-disciplinary teams and commissioners to work together to see if they can improve take up of this vital test which may affect patients and their families.”

Bowel cancer is the UK’s second biggest cancer killer and the fourth most common cancer. More than 2,400 people under 50 are diagnosed with bowel cancer in the UK every year. While this is only five per cent of people diagnosed with the disease, there has been a 25 per cent increase in the number of under 50s diagnosed in the past 10 years. Nationally, three out of five people diagnosed under the age of 50 will be diagnosed in the later stages of the disease when chances of survival are lower.

Bowel Cancer UK and the Royal College of Pathologists will be submitting the findings of this Freedom of Information request to The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) ahead of the publication of their guidance on testing for Lynch syndrome in October.

The charity’s work to to improve the identification and management of people diagnosed with Lynch syndrome is a core part of our flagship Never Too Young campaign.

(The findings are based on a Freedom of Information request which we submitted to 185 hospitals across the UK in May 2016. 156 hospitals (84%) responded.)

– See more at: https://www.bowelcanceruk.org.uk/media-centre/news-and-blog/new-findings-show-variation-of-genetic-testing-in-the-uk-could-lead-to-cancer-devastating-whole-families/#sthash.n4lYp5fw.dpuf

New survey for people with Lynch Syndrome in the UK


bowelcancerukBowel Cancer UK is campaigning to improve the identification and management of people with Lynch syndrome.

They’ve put together a 15 minute survey to give people the chance, anonymously, to share their experience of being diagnosed, and managed for Lynch syndrome.

https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/lsexperience 

Your experiences will help Bowel Cancer UK to continue to campaign to improve the diagnosis and management of Lynch syndrome.

Please share the survey with your family and friends who also have Lynch syndrome.

Bowel Cancer UK research highlights variation in Lynch syndrome testing


BowelCancerUKHalf of NHS authorities in England, Scotland and Wales do not currently test bowel cancer patients under 50 for possible Lynch syndrome.

Read the data briefing here

 

Bowel Cancer UK concerned about wide variations in approach to testing for Lynch syndrome among hospitals that do test.

A Freedom of Information (FOI) request by leading charity Bowel Cancer UK has highlighted a wide  variation in tests for Lynch syndrome in bowel cancer patients under 50. Lynch syndrome is an inherited condition which can mean a higher risk of developing bowel cancer. Testing for Lynch syndrome will help identify family members who may have the condition and be at risk of bowel cancer. It can also affect treatment options. Lynch syndrome testing has been shown to be cost effective for the NHS, and is a required reflex test mandated by the Royal College of Pathologists and recommended by the British Society of Gastroenterologists.

Despite this testing is patchy. Just half of the hospital trusts in England that responded to the FOI request said they conduct tests among bowel cancer patients under 50 for Lynch syndrome, 10 of the trusts saying they had no plans to do so.

It’s not just England hospital trusts that are falling short.  More than half of health boards in Wales do not screen patients under 50 with bowel cancer. In Scotland fifty per cent of health boards currently do not follow the guidelines for Lynch syndrome testing set in July last year by the Royal College of Pathologists.  It’s a brighter picture in Northern Ireland where all health and social care trusts responded to say that they perform the test to identify possible Lynch syndrome patients.

The approach to testing is also widely varied among those hospitals which do screening for bowel cancer patients under 50. Testing is part of the core dataset for pathologists and should therefore be carried out automatically (known as reflex testing) for this group of young patients. However many trusts/health boards do not yet carry out this “reflex testing,” as stipulated in the Royal College of Pathologists’ guidelines.  Scotland is in the process of developing a nationwide approach to testing. We believe a nationwide approach would provide the consistency needed to ensure all bowel cancer patients under 50 are systematically tested.

Bowel Cancer UK submitted the FOI request in November 2014 to every NHS trust in England, health board in Scotland and health and social care trust in Northern Ireland to establish the number of trusts/health boards which were implementing the testing for all bowel cancer patients under 50, as mandated by the Royal College of Pathologists.  Lynch syndrome is responsible for around one in 12 cases of bowel cancer in people aged under 50.

Dr Suzy Lishman, President of the Royal College of Pathologists, said, “This research is encouraging as it shows that our guidelines may have had some impact already on testing for Lynch syndrome in patients diagnosed under the age of 50. However, there is considerable variation in the approach to testing.  Testing is now mandated by the Royal College of Pathologists as part of the core dataset for pathology and is a required reflex test for this group of young patients.  We would urge all trusts to perform the screening test for Lynch syndrome in bowel cancer patients under 50  and to adopt a more consistent approach to the testing.”

Deborah Alsina, Chief Executive of Bowel Cancer UK said, “We welcome the fact that some trusts and health bodies have implemented this guidance, but it is concerning that variation still remains. The disparity between hospital trusts and health boards in England, Wales and Scotland is even greater than we anticipated.”

“It’s crucially important that all bowel cancer patients under 50 are offered genetic testing at diagnosis as it could affect both surgical and chemotherapy decision making.   Yet currently it is normally done after treatment has ended, if at all.   Not only that, but appropriate surveillance needs to be arranged as patients with Lynch syndrome are at greater risk of recurrence.  Additionally, as Lynch syndrome is a genetic condition, it can have implications for other family members who may be at risk of developing bowel cancer so family members should also be tested to identify any others with the condition.”

Andy Sutton, the father of teenager Stephen Sutton who sadly died last year from bowel cancer, is all too aware of the need for systematic Lynch syndrome testing.  Andy was diagnosed with bowel cancer twice – in 1989 at the age of 31 and 20 years later in 2009.  It was only second time round that Andy was tested for Lynch syndrome, which was inherited by his son, Stephen.

Andy said, “If I had been genetically tested after the first diagnosis and given regular surveillance screening, it might have been possible to have prevented bowel cancer developing second time around.  That’s why I’m supporting Bowel Cancer UK’s call for everyone under the age of 50 who is diagnosed with bowel cancer to have testing for Lynch syndrome, it had a tragic impact on our family and I want to save others from going through the same experience.”

Dr Kevin Monahan, Consultant Gastroenterologist and General Physician, Family History of Bowel Cancer Clinic, West Middlesex University Hospital says: “Anyone under 50 who is diagnosed with bowel cancer is eligible for testing but it is not always offered. In the first instance, discuss testing for Lynch syndrome with your consultant or your GP”

Bowel Cancer UK is calling for urgent action to be taken:
1. We would urge NHS England and Wales to adopt a similar approach to NHS Scotland and establish a nationwide initiative to ensure a consistent, systematic approach to screening for Lynch syndrome as mandated by the Royal College of Pathologists.
2. All CCGs must commission to reflect the RCPath cancer dataset thus ensuring providers are compliant with this cancer dataset.
3. Accreditation of pathology departments should be linked to compliance with the core minimum dataset which may be used as a metric.

Controversial 23andMe DNA test comes to UK


indexA personal DNA test that has sparked controversy in the US has been approved for use in the UK by regulators.

The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) says the 23andMe spit test, which is designed to give details about a person’s health risks based on their DNA, can be used with caution.

But critics say it may not be accurate enough to base health decisions on.

The company, California-based 23andMe, stands by its test.

Backed by Google, the firm offered US customers details of health risks based on gene variants they carry.

But in November 2013, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) banned the company from marketing its service in the US, claiming 23andMe had failed to provide adequate information to support the claims it made about results.

A month later, the company stopped offering genetic tests related to health.

‘Think carefully’

An MHRA spokesperson said it regulated such tests in the UK to make sure they met minimum standards.

23andMe’s mission is to ensure that individuals can personally access, understand and benefit from the human genome”

Anne Wojcicki Chief executive, 23andMe

“People who use these products should ensure that they are CE marked and remember that no test is 100% reliable so think carefully before using personal genome services.

“If after using the service, you have any questions or concerns you should speak to your healthcare professional.”

She added: “If you are concerned that you have an incorrect result due to a faulty product, you can report this to MHRA at aic@mhra.gsi.gov.uk or 020 3080 7080.”

The UK Department of Health said it was behind the idea of using gene tests to guide patient care within the NHS, but echoed the MHRA advice on giving careful consideration before opting for services like the one offered by 23andMe.

23andMe chief executive Anne Wojcicki said: “The UK is a world leader in genomics and we are very excited to offer a product specifically for UK customers.”

Ms Wojcicki is separated from but still legally married to Sergey Brin, the co-founder of Google – which has invested millions in 23andMe.

The company had previously offered results on a customer’s risk for 254 diseases and conditions, including identifying genes linked to heart disease and breast cancer. There was also information on how individuals might respond to certain medicines.

Genetic testing is an important medical tool in certain situations, but for healthy people as a way to predict common complex diseases, it’s pretty useless”

Dr Marcy Darnovsky Center for Genetics and Society

But the FDA said the reliability of such tests had not been proven to its satisfaction. It was also worried that some customers could make life-changing decisions based solely on their results.

The UK Department of Health said the product launched in Britain was very different to the service halted by the US regulator.

“Many of the drug responses, inherited conditions and genetic health risks that were of concern in the US have been removed,” a spokesperson told BBC News.

In October, 23andMe said it would sell kits in Canada – these too contain only a handful of health-related results.

“I think a large part of it is trying to expand their markets,” said Professor Hank Greely, director of the Center for Law and the Biosciences at Stanford University in California.

“They may also want to make it clear to the public, to their investors, to their employees that they’re alive and kicking.”

 

‘Understandable concern that this type of genetic testing’

23andMe said it does not share the genetic data with insurance companies or any other interested party without a person’s explicit consent.

“The science is soundest behind 23andMe’s ancestry reports, which are good, but the majority of the rest of the reports are generally based on very small shifts of risk, which are better served by simply living healthier and getting more exercise,” said Dr Ewan Birney – associate director of the EMBL-European Bioinformatics Institute in Cambridge and unconnected with 23andMe, although he has used one of its kits.

“Despite 23andMe’s careful use of language and explanation, there is an understandable concern that this type of genetic testing could cause inappropriate harm simply through people worrying excessively or becoming neurotic over these small increases in risk.”

In the UK, 23andMe is not the first to launch genetic testing. The NHS’s 100,000 genome project conducts full genome sequencing as opposed to genotyping, whichcompares common differences in known genes. The NHS’s project, which is set to complete its pilot stage by 2017 as part of analysing how best to use genomic data in health care, is “world leading”, said Birney.

“This government is developing the use of genomics for patient care within the NHS,” a Department of Health spokesperson said. “We welcome initiatives that help to raise awareness of genomics and those which enable people to take more interest in their personal health but we urge people to think carefully before using private genomic services as no test is 100per cent reliable.”

“For the curious and the scientists, 23andMe is fine, it’s fun and you can have a ball with your ancestry, but for the general population the NHS is truly working out how best to use this in a way that is world leading,” said Birney. “If you’re waiting for the technology to catch up with you, the NHS will deliver.”

 

 

What’s the plan?

Dr Marcy Darnovsky, executive director of the Center for Genetics and Society in California, said the UK and Canadian launches could be a way of placing pressure on the FDA by demonstrating that regulators in other countries found no fault with their product.

“Genetic testing is an important medical tool in certain situations, but for healthy people as a way to predict common complex diseases, it’s pretty useless,” she told BBC News.

“Most complex diseases and almost all the common ones – with some exceptions such as the BRCA 1 and 2 genes (implicated in breast cancer) – are multi-factorial with many genes and other biological, social and environmental causes.”

What happens to the data gathered by 23andMe also concerns some people. “It’s not entirely clear what their business plan is – whether they want to make money by selling kits to consumers, or whether they want to make most of their money by selling consumer data to other companies,” Prof Greely told BBC News.

But Ms Wojcicki believes the information provided to customers is empowering. “23andMe’s mission is to ensure that individuals can personally access, understand and benefit from the human genome,” she said.

Commenting on the announcement, Mark Thomas, professor of evolutionary genetics at University College London, said: “For better or worse, direct-to-the-consumer genetic testing companies are here to stay.

“One could argue the rights and wrongs of such companies existing, but I suspect that ship has sailed.”

We support Lynch syndrome testing and bowel cancer in people under 50


https://i1.wp.com/www.bowelcanceruk.org.uk/media/414473/lynch_syndrome_and_bowel_cancer_november_2014.jpgBowel Cancer UK and clinical experts are urging all hospitals across the UK to implement Lynch syndrome testing at diagnosis for everyone with bowel cancer under the age of 50. Lynch syndrome is an inherited condition which causes over 1,000 cases of bowel cancer in the UK every year, many of them in people under the age of 50. However, fewer than 5% of people with Lynch syndrome in the UK have been diagnosed.

Testing everyone with bowel cancer under the age of 50 at diagnosis for Lynch syndrome will help identify family members who may carry Lynch syndrome and be at risk of bowel cancer. It has been shown to be cost effective for the NHS, and is recommended by the Royal College of Pathologists and British Society of Gastroenterologists. It is also a key recommendation in our Never Too Young campaign.

People with Lynch syndrome should then access regular surveillance screening, which can detect bowel cancer in the early stages and has been shown to reduce mortaility from bowel cancer by 72%.

Despite this, testing and surveillance screening are patchy across the UK. A letter in the Daily Telegraph (13 November 2014) from eight leading clinical experts supports our call for all hospitals to implement Lynch syndrome testing at diagnosis for people with bowel cancer under the age of 50.

The letter and signatories are as follows:

Dear Editor

There are more than 1,000 cases of bowel cancer a year that are attributable to Lynch syndrome (LS), many under the age of 50. LS is an inherited condition that predisposes individuals to bowel and other cancers, with a lifetime risk of around 70 per cent. Yet in the UK we have identified fewer than 5 per cent of families with LS. The family of Stephen Sutton, who was diagnosed with bowel cancer and whose father has LS, was one of them. It is a consistently under-recognised, under-diagnosed and inadequately treated condition.

Both the Royal College of Pathologists and the British Society of Gastroenterology recommend testing everyone with bowel cancer under the age of 50 at diagnosis to help us to identify family members who may carry LS and be at risk of bowel cancer. Yet testing is patchy. We urge all hospitals across the UK to implement this guidance.

This testing would mean people at risk could access surveillance programmes for regular colonoscopies, helping detecting bowel cancer early but also preventing it.

Patient groups such as Bowel Cancer UK are in support. A recent NHS study found that LS testing at diagnosis for everyone under 50 with bowel cancer would be cost effective enough to have been approved by NICE. The evidence is overwhelming. We must end this postcode lottery.

Dr Kevin Monahan, Consultant Gastroenterologist and General Physician at Family History of Bowel Cancer Clinic, West Middlesex University Hospital (WMUH), London

Professor Sue Clark, Chair of the Colorectal Section of the British Society of Gastroenterology, Consultant Colorectal Surgeon, St Mark’s Hospital

Professor John Schofield, Consultant Pathologist, Cellular Pathology Department, Maidstone Hospital and Kent Cancer Centre

Dr Suzy Lishman, President, The Royal College of Pathologists

Professor Ian Tomlinson, Professor of Molecular and Population Genetics, Group Head / PI and Consultant Physician, Wellcome Trust Centre for Human Genetics

Professor Huw JW Thomas, Consultant Gastroenterologist, Family Cancer Clinic, St Mark’s Hospital, London

Professor Malcolm Dunlop MD FRCS FMedSci FRSE, Colon Cancer Genetics Group and Academic Coloproctology, Head of Colon Cancer Genetics, Institute of Genetics & Molecular Medicine

Professor D Gareth Evans MD FRCP, Professor of Clinical Genetics and Cancer Epidemiology and Consultant Geneticist, University of Manchester

Commenting on the letter from clinical experts, Deborah Alsina, CEO of Bowel Cancer UK, said:

“The Royal College of Pathologists recently produced best practice guidelines recommending everyone with bowel cancer under the age of 50 should be tested for Lynch syndrome at diagnosis. Speedy implementation is vital as testing is currently patchy at best and if people are tested at all, it is often after treatment ends.  Yet a diagnosis of Lynch syndrome can affect treatment decisions. We are therefore calling for all UK hospitals to implement this guidance swiftly.”

“This will also help to identify the risk to other family members who may also carry Lynch syndrome and who may be at higher risk of developing bowel cancer. Once identified, people at risk, including those diagnosed who have a greater chance of recurring or developing another linked cancer, should have access to surveillance programmes including regular colonoscopies. This will help to ensure bowel cancer is either prevented or detected early.”

Bowel Cancer UK will be writing to all Clinical Commissioning Groups and Health Trusts in the UK asking them if they have implemented systematic Lynch syndrome testing, and we will report back on the responses. In the meantime, please share our infographic on the subject on social media to help raise awareness of the issue.

Inherited Colorectal Cancer Course for the Multidisciplinary Team, London 15th January 2015


 

Date: January 15th, 2015

Venue: St Mark’s Hospital, London

Click here for more information

Target Audience:  All members of the Colorectal Cancer MDT (nurse specialists, oncologists, gastroenterologists, colorectal surgeons, pathologists), Geneticists, genetics counsellors

Learning Style: Lectures and case discussions

Learning Outcomes: On completion of this course, attendees will:

  • Appreciate the contribution of inheritance to colorectal cancer
  • Be able to assess family history and associated risk
  • Understand how to manage individuals at moderate risk of colorectal cancer
  • Understand the basic features and management of polyposis syndromes
  • Understand the diagnosis and management of Lynch syndrome

Course Fees:

£150.00 – Consultants
£75.00 – Nurses, Trainees and other Healthcare Professionals

To apply, complete the application form and send to nwlh-tr.StMarksAcademicInstitute@nhs.net.

For further information, view the programme and brochure for the course. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact the Academic Institute.

Bowel Cancer UK Campaign: People at high risk of bowel cancer


Bowel Cancer UKFrom Bowel Cancer UK: Read more here

Our briefing highlights the lack of surveillance screening for younger people at higher risk of bowel cancer.

Genetic factors contribute up to 30% of bowel cancer cases, an estimated 8,000-12,000 cases each year.

Genetic factors mean a strong family history of bowel cancer, or genetic conditions such as familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP) or Lynch syndrome. People with long-term inflammatory bowel disease are also at higher risk.

Research findings

People in higher risk groups are likely to develop bowel cancer much younger than the general population. Clinical guidance recommends that people in high-risk groups should be in a surveillance screening programme, which is proven to reduce deaths in these groups.

Recent evidence shows that:

  • People diagnosed are not routinely tested for genetic conditions, and only a third of centres identify and manage high-risk patients through a registry.
  • Even when they are in a surveillance programme, patients may have to wait a long time for their screening colonoscopy. Thirty-five hospitals offering a surveillance programme have a waiting time of over 26 weeks (6 months) for people at higher risk.
  • More than half of centres do not have a programme for managing high-risk groups.
  • 64% of clinicians believed that someone else should be carrying out the surveillance work.

Recommendations

Our briefing, “Never too young: Supporting people at higher risk of bowel cancer”, has five recommendations to improve services for people in high risk groups:

  1. Better surveillance screening for those at high risk of developing bowel cancer.
  2. Clear information should be made available for GPs and the public on who may be at higher risk of bowel cancer.
  3. As people with a genetic condition such as Lynch syndrome typically develop bowel cancer at a young age, anyone diagnosed with bowel cancer under the age of 50 should have a genetic test for these conditions, so they and their families can be included in a surveillance programme.
  4. Adequate endoscopy service capacity to ensure that people at high risk do not have a long wait for their colonoscopy.
  5. Designation of a single named lead person in each hospital trust with responsibility for a registry of people at higher risk.

Full details of our findings and recommendations are in our full report available here.

Enhanced by Zemanta

A national survey of hereditary colorectal cancer services in the United Kingdom


Autosomal dominant pedigree chart. In Autosoma...

A new study has just been published in the journal Frontline Gastroenterology.  This shows a highly inconsistent approach to the management of patients at elevated risk of hereditary colorectal cancer (CRC) in the United Kingdom (UK). 

The British Society of Gastroenterology (BSG) Cancer Group designed a national survey to determine how we might understand and improve the service for these patients.

What is already known on this topic? Genetic factors contribute about 35% of all colorectal cancer (CRC) risk.  There is good evidence that the correct management of patients with an elevated hereditary risk is a highly effective method of preventing CRC.  This can be achieved by screening according to guidelines and the development of a high quality service with clear patient pathways.  However in some studies there is evidence of an inconsistent approach to the management of those patients, with low risk patients being screened too often, and high risk patients not frequently enough.  There is also a low referral rate to genetic services for high risk patients.

What this study adds? Responses to this national survey suggest a poor understanding of the current guidelines amongst clinicians and variable clinical pathways for patients.  There is also a perception that another unspecified clinician is undertaking this work.  This may explain the wide variation in care and low adherence to guidelines in the United Kingdom (UK).

How might it impact on clinical practice in the foreseeable future? We recommend the development of clear structures and the provision of a high quality service to these patients through national audit, development of quality standards and education of physicians and surgeons in the UK.  Each hospital should develop a lead clinician for the delivery of these services.  Only in this way will this ad hoc approach to the management of hereditary CRC be improved.

Study Reference: Kevin Monahan & Susan Clark.  Frontline Gastroenterology. 2013 Online First

Abstract 

Objectives: The British Society of Gastroenterology (BSG) Cancer Group designed a survey to determine how we might understand and improve the service for patients at elevated risk of hereditary colorectal cancer (CRC).

Design and Setting: United Kingdom (UK) gastroenterologists, colorectal surgeons, and oncologists were invited by email to complete a 10 point questionnaire. This was cascaded to 1,793 members of the Royal College of Radiologists (RCR), Association of Cancer Physicians (ACP), the Association of Coloproctology of Great Britain and Ireland (ACPGBI), as well as BSG members.
Results:  Three hundred and eighty-two members responded to the survey, an overall response rate of 21.3%. Although 69% of respondents felt there was an adequate service for these higher risk patients, 64% believed that another clinician was undertaking this work. There was no apparent formal patient pathway in 52% of centres, and only 33% of centres maintain a registry of these patients. Tumour block testing for Lynch Syndrome is not usual practice. Many appeared to be unaware of the BSG/ACPGBI UK guidelines for the management of these patients.
Conclusions: There is wide variability in local management and in subsequent clinical pathways for hereditary CRC patients. There is a perception that they are being managed by ‘another’, unspecified clinician. National guidelines are not adhered to. We therefore recommend improved education, well defined pathways and cyclical audit in order to improve care of patients with hereditary CRC risk.

UK colorectal cancer patients are inadequately assessed for Lynch syndrome.


Our new study shows that we can do much more to identify patients with Lynch syndrome in the UK. We already know that diagnosing Lynch syndrome can affect the treatment of a patient with bowel cancer – and can save the lives of their family members. Every team dealing with bowel cancer patients needs to routinely discuss the possibility of an inherited cancer syndrome.  This study has just been published in the journal ‘Frontline Gastroenterology’.

Lynch syndrome is the most common familial bowel cancer syndrome. European guidelines suggest selective screening of appropriate colorectal cancer patients, according to the revised Bethesda criteria. Many eligible patients do not undergo the necessary investigation.

What this study adds

This is the first time that UK practice in this area has been evaluated. Our patients are assessed haphazardly for Lynch syndrome, and we do not follow international guidance. This will lead to under-diagnosis and missed opportunities to reduce cancer mortality. impact on clinical practice in the foreseeable

Colorectal cancer teams should incorporate a revised Bethesda assessment into the routine discussion of each new patient. They should develop screening and referral pathways with their local genetics services. This aspect of their work can be audited and may become a quality standard in the future.

The “Family History of Bowel Cancer” clinic at the West Middlesex University Hospital, led by Dr Kevin Monahan, helps assess patients with a significant family background of cancers.  Patients, GPs and other health professionals can read more about our service, and how to make a referral, at https://familyhistorybowelcancer.wordpress.com.

Contact: bowelcancer@wmuh.nhs.uk

Article: UK colorectal cancer patients are inadequately assessed for Lynch syndrome. Maria Adelson, Samuel Pannick, James E East, Peter Risby, Peter Dawson, Kevin J Monahan

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,364 other followers

Live twitter feed

RSS CRUK Bowel Cancer Blog

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Familial Cancer

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Categories

Google Plus

%d bloggers like this: